Are Mechanical Broadheads Effective for Elk Hunting?

Are mechanical broadheads truly effective for elk hunting?

This debate splits the hunting community down the middle, with some lauding their impeccable accuracy and others criticizing their occasional lack of penetration.

It’s clear that you need a reliable tool that ensures an ethical kill, and many hunters find this in fixed-blade broadheads.

But the choice isn’t as simple as it seems.

Cutting diameter, blade angles, number of blades, bow energy, draw length, and draw weight are all influential factors that merit careful consideration.

So, as we unpack this complex issue, we invite you to stay with us and gain the insight you need to make the best decision for your hunt.

Understanding Mechanical Broadheads

Let’s dive into understanding mechanical broadheads, their structure, functionality, and why they may or may not be the best choice for elk hunting.

Mechanical broadheads are a type of arrow tip that expands upon impact.

When you shoot your arrow, the mechanical broadhead is closed. Giving you flight characteristics similar to field points.

As it hits the target, the blades open – theoretically causing more damage to the game.

Now, you might be thinking, ‘Sounds great, right?’

Well, it’s not that clear-cut when it comes to elk hunting.

The argument against using mechanical broadheads for elk hunting is all about penetration.

Elk are large, robust animals with thick hides and tough bones.

Mechanical broadheads, while offering larger cut diameters, mightn’t penetrate as deeply as fixed blade broadheads because they use some of the arrow’s energy to open the blades.

Are mechanical broadheads effective for elk hunting?

The answer varies from person to person. However, numerous hunters, including John Dudley, have achieved significant success.

In my view, provided your bow generates sufficient kinetic energy, mechanical broadheads can perform equally well, if not better, than fixed blades.

They often lead to more substantial blood trails, increased damage, and thus, a more ethical kill.

Broadhead Selection Criteria for Elk Hunting


When selecting a broadhead for elk hunting, factors like penetration depth, cutting diameter, the kinetic energy delivered, and your trust in the gear are crucial to consider.

Additionally, your choice should take into account your bow’s energy, draw length, and draw weight.

These elements significantly affect how well your broadheads perform.

read.. best broadheads for elk

Greater kinetic energy can compensate for the energy that mechanical broadheads might lose.

Comparing Mechanical and Fixed Broadheads

Diving into the debate between mechanical and fixed broadheads, you’ll find pros and cons to each, heavily influenced by personal preference and hunting style.

When comparing mechanical and fixed broadheads, one of the key factors to consider is penetration.

Mechanical broadheads are often touted for their accuracy, but for elk hunting, penetration is paramount.

Fixed broadheads tend to excel in this area, providing a more reliable pass-through, crucial for bringing down the robust elk.

Mechanical broadheads have their fans too, with many hunters citing their wide cutting diameter and with this better blood trails.

It’s not all about the broadhead itself.

Shot placement and accuracy, influenced by your confidence in your equipment and shooting ability, also play a significant role.

Before you go..

Finding the right broadhead for elk? It’s all about what works for you—your gear, the terrain, and your gut feeling out there.

Fixed blades and mechanical broadheads each have distinct benefits: fixed blades excel in durability and penetration, while mechanical broadheads provide broader cutting paths and improved flight characteristics.

Chat with other hunters, and test things out yourself.

It’s not just tech specs; it’s about what feels right in your hands.

Happy hunting!


Leave a Comment

a diy hotbox for bow making
Alexander Knobloch

DIY How to Make a Cheap and Easy Hotbox

Special Thanks to Sam Harper for allowing us to republish his tutorials and build along instructions. His expertise and knowledge in the bow-making field have greatly benefited many readers, and we are grateful for his generous permission. My hot box cost me about $20 to make. Here’s how I did it. First, I went to

Read More »
How Important Is Paper Tuning?
Alexander Knobloch

How Important Is Paper Tuning?

So, you’ve been practicing with your bow for some time now, and everything seems to be working and running just fine. And yet, something still feels off. Everything is in tip-top condition, and yet there’s still something that is stopping you from getting your aim right. Maybe your arrows wiggle a little too much, or

Read More »
Darren Webster

BlackOut S3 [Review]

The BlackOut S3 Compound Bow Package is an ultra-accurate and low-maintenance bow to suit your hunting needs. This right-handed compound bow features the speedy BlackOut performance of their other products, and the design partners at Bowtech engineered it for the best results. BlackOut produces user-friendly and adjustable compound bows to fit your needs. With impressive

Read More »