Search
Close this search box.

Best Broadheads For Elk Hunting 2024

best broadheads for elk

Nothing quite matches the adrenaline surge of an elk hunt. These massive, hardy creatures need equally sturdy and reliable gear to take down – especially for broadheads. Aiming for a clean, ethical kill requires you to equip your bow with a superior broadhead. If you’re preparing for your next thrilling chase, our top pick – the G5 Outdoors Montec M3 Broadhead – may be the broadhead you’re looking for.

If you’ve taken the time to trek across country, paid well over $650 for a tag, and worn miles of boot leather to take the shot at a bull elk screaming in your face the last thing you want is to lose him due to equipment failure. One of those potential weak points… is a weak point. Your broad head is what we are propelling with our arrow to do the job. That job is penetrating the vital organs and doing enough damage to bring an animal down.

At a Glance, Recommended Broadheads For Big Game

+ G5 Outdoors Montec M3. These heads are shaving-sharp and constructed from a one-piece solid design that eliminates the need for replacement blades.
___________________
+ Magnus Stinger Buzzcut 4-Blade. The Magnus Stinger Buzzcut is designed to be simplistic, yet devastating, leading to a deadly broadhead that can be trusted when the fate of a once-in-a-lifetime hunt is on the line.
___________________
+ Wasp Hammer SST. Good heads that fly well and kill even better. Stainless Steel Trocar Tip. 100 grain – 1-3/16″ Cutting Diameter
___________________
+ Wasp Boss SST 4-Blade. Perfect for a high-power bow, these 4-blade arrowheads provides razor-sharp blades that can punch through bone in deer and similar targets
___________________
+ Magnus Snuffer SS. At 125 grain, this is one of the heavier broadheads on the market. Magnus uses a standard three-barb design for this, with the arrow immediately cutting on contact instead of chiseling through first
___________________
+ NAP Hellrazor 60-410. The one-piece design helps support their strength, giving impressive consistency for broadheads in this price range
___________________
+ Slick Trick Magnum. These Slick Trick heads are also known for their high level of accuracy straight out of the package
___________________
+ Innerloc Shape Shifter Broadhead. Innerloc’s shape-shifting broadhead is an excellent mechanical broadhead for an arrow, flying rather dart-like and spreading on impact to cut into deer and other animals you’re hunting
___________________
+ Muzzy Trocar. The Trocar 3-Blade Broadhead carries on the company’s hard-hitting tradition with its hardened trocar tip and solid steel ferrule that will not deform, even when hitting bone. Delivers the kinetic energy where you want it

The Essence of Deep Penetration

Elk are not just large; they possess deep body cavities. Thus, the efficacy of a broadhead is directly proportional to its ability to penetrate vital organs within this cavity. When shot from a bow of adequate poundage, a top-notch broadhead can traverse the depth of an elk’s body cavity.

This results in two distinct wounds – an entrance and an exit wound.

Wound Channels

A broadhead’s sole purpose is to create wounds that cause rapid blood loss and a quick, humane kill. The larger and nastier the wound channel, the faster your target bleeds out. Conversely, the wider and larger the broadhead the less penetration you will see due to increased fraction. You may wonder what’s better: fixed blades or mechanical broadheads?

An Expert’s Take: John Dudley on Fixed-Blade vs. Mechanical Broadheads

John Dudley, a seasoned elk hunter with over 15 years of success, weighs in on the pivotal decision between fixed-blade and mechanical broadheads. He has brought down around two dozen bulls in his hunting career, with a balanced kill record using fixed blades and mechanical heads. According to Dudley, the choice is a trade-off between superior penetration (fixed blades) or better flight characteristics (mechanical heads).

Both options can lead to successful hunts, so it ultimately boils down to personal preference and the specifics of the hunt.

Comparison: Broadhead Physical Dimensions

ManufacturerModel# BladesTypeCutting Dia.BladeWeight
G5Montec3fixed1-1/8″85-125
WaspHammer SST3replace1-3/16″.027″75-125
WaspBoss4replace1-1/8”.027″100
MagnusSnuffer SS3fixed1-1/8″125
NAPHellrazor3fixed1-1/8″100
InnerlocShape Shifter3mech.1 1/4″.040″100
Slick TrickMagnum4replace1-1/8″100-125
MuzzyTrocar3replace1 3/16”.035″100
Rage2-Blade2mech.2″.039″100
MagnusStinger Buzzcut2 (4)replacedepends85-125

Broadheads for Elk: Recommendations and Reviews

G5 Outdoors Montec M3

G5 Outdoors Montec

G5 Outdoors Montec – 85-125 grain -1″- 1 1/8″ cutting diameter


Built with rugged dependability in mind, the G5 Outdoors Montec Broadhead is your stalwart companion, standing tall even amidst the most challenging hunting conditions.

Crafted for Durability: One-Piece Design

This hunting broadhead sets itself apart with its single-piece construction, making it one of the most reliable fixed-blade broadheads on the market.

The unified design means you don’t need to bother about replacing blades. Those broadhead blades aren’t just sturdy – they are razor-sharp and ready to meet your hunting needs!

After a successful hunt, give your broadhead a close inspection, sharpen it, and it’s ready to return to your quiver, eagerly awaiting your next hunting adventure.

Specs:

  • Cutting Diameter: 1″- 1 1/8″
  • Weight: 100 grains (available from 85 to 125 grains)

Tip:

  • Cut-on-Contact

Features & Benefits:

  • Solid steel construction offering unsurpassed durability
  • One-piece Fixed Blade Broadhead for worry-free usage
  • Ensures optimal kinetic energy delivery for a successful hunt
  • Factory spin-tested for enhanced flight characteristics
  • Razor-sharp blades, ready to use right out of the package
  • Easily sharpened to ensure longevity and repeated use

Precision Sharpened and Spin-Tested

These broadheads come with surgical precision sharpening and are spin-tested straight from the factory.

This leads to improved penetration and lethal performance on the field. But remember, handle carefully while unpacking – you wouldn’t want to cut your fingers on these sharp fellows!

Magnus Stinger Buzzcut 4-Blade

Magnus Stinger Buzzcut 4-Blade

Magnus Stinger Buzzcut – 85 -125 grain – 1 1/16″ cutting diameter


The Magnus Stinger Buzzcut is designed to be simplistic yet devastating, leading to a deadly broadhead that can be trusted when the fate of a once-in-a-lifetime hunt is on the line.

These heads are constructed from knife-grade stainless steel and are razor-sharp right out of the package for next-level penetration.

The Magnus Stinger Buzzcut also features chiseled serrations for increased tissue damage – making it a feasible hunting broadhead for big game hunting.

It´s a two-blade broadhead with two additional small bleeder blades.

Specs:

  • Cutting Diameter: 1 1/16”
  • Weight: 85 grain, 100 grain, 125 grain

Tip:

  • Cut-on-contact

Features & Benefits:

  • Extremely sharp blades come in one piece from the factory for excellent penetration
  • Constructed of knife grade stainless steel for durability
  • Serrations cause increased tissue damage and lead to shorter blood trails
  • Replaceable Blade (the main blade)

The Magnus Stinger Buzzcut doesn’t just inflict damage; it ensures quicker recoveries. Its design promotes increased blood loss, resulting in shorter blood trails. This feature is a game-changer, especially for big game hunts, as it allows for easier and quicker recoveries.

Moreover, Magnus also issues a lifetime warranty with these heads. If one ever becomes damaged, rest assured that a replacement will be issued.

It’s not just one of the finest broadheads for elk; it’s a lifetime investment for any bowhunter aiming to take down tough game.

Wasp Hammer SST

Wasp Hammer SST 100 Grain Broadhead

Wasp Hammer SST – 100 grain – 1-3/16″ cutting diameter


What truly sets this broadhead apart, however, is the flexibility it offers in terms of weight.

While the 100-grain variant is the most popular, Wasp also ensures that every archer’s needs are catered to by offering this in 75, 85, 90, and 125-grain variants.

This is ideal for those who understand that a heavier arrow is key to achieving maximum penetration.

Essentially, this means you can obtain the weight you desire without compromising on quality and have many options to tweak your setup perfectly.

Specs:

  • Cutting Diameter: 1-3/16”
  • Weight: 100 grain (available in other weights)

Tip:

  • Chisel tip

Features & Benefits:

  • Sturdy blades that don’t bend when they impact the ground after hitting a deer
  • Available in many different weights
  • Strong enough to punch through steel
  • Razor-sharp edges help bleed targets quickly.

This set of three arrowheads may not come with the same replacement heads as the Boss SST 4-Blades from Wasp, making it seem less of a deal initially.

However, considering the larger cutting diameter these broadheads offer, you’ll realize they’re more than worth the investment.

Wasp Boss SST 4-Blades

Wasp Archery Products Boss SST 4-Blade...

Wasp Boss SST – 100 grain – 1-1/16″ cutting diameter


Wasp is one of the industry’s better brands, and as long as you are shooting a high power bow, their 4-blade arrowheads provide some distinct advantages when hunting elk.

The razor-sharp blades can punch through bone in deer and similar targets, while the spread of the cutting blades helps bleed out your targets much faster.

This set comes with three heads and two sets of replacement blades so you can keep using the same arrowheads.

Specs:

  • Cutting Diameter: 1-1/8”
  • Weight: 100 grain

Tip:

  • Chisel tip

Features & Benefits:

  • Penetrates deep into targets thanks to its reduced blade surface
  • Comes with two sets of replacement blades
  • Sharp straight from the factory
  • Shoots like field point arrows

This is a moderately expensive head, but it’s hard to match the sheer quality or factory sharpness here. The replacement blades are what really seal this deal, however.

That is why we enthusiastically recommend the Wasp Boss SST 4-Blade if you’re looking for a premium broadhead and use a high power bow setup, you’re good to go!

Magnus Snuffer SS

MAGNUS OUTDOOR PRODUCTS Snuffer SS 125gr

Magnus Snuffer SS – 125 grain – 1″ cutting diameter


At 125 grain, this is one of the heavier broadheads on the market. Magnus uses a standard three-barb design for this, with the arrow immediately cutting on contact instead of chiseling through first.

This broadhead is quite as good as most of the other options on this list, the heat-tempered stainless steel is durable, and the anti-vibration tips are useful in scenarios where that’s a problem. This head will allow you to take almost any game animal.

Specs:

  • Cutting Diameter: 1-1/8″
  • Weight: 125 grain

Tip:

  • Cut-on-contact

Features & Benefits:

  • Fits 5/16 shafts
  • Sturdy central pillar for support on penetration
  • Easy to sharpen yourself if needed

The main virtue of this broadhead is its simplicity. The overall design gives it excellent strength and durability, while the weight makes it suitable for heavier crossbows and similar equipment.

It’s one of our top choices for elk and way better than the average broadhead.

NAP Hellrazor 60-410

NAP Hellrazor 60-410

NAP Hellrazor 60-410 – 100 grain – 1-1/8” cutting diameter


This pack features three broadheads with three blades each, which is functionally standard for the industry. At 1-1/8” for the cutting diameter, they’re a little wider than some other products.

The one-piece design helps support their strength, giving impressive consistency for broadheads in this price range.

Specs:

  • Cutting Diameter: 1-1/8”
  • Weight: 100 grain

Tip:

  • Cut-on-contact

Features & Benefits:

  • Photon blade bonding for extra strength
  • One-piece design with no weak joints
  • Comes with a one-year limited warranty
  • Easy to resharpen

These broadheads aren’t always the sharpest right out of the pack, but that’s easy to fix because sharpening them is straightforward.

Innerloc Shape Shifter Broadhead

Innerloc Shape Shifter 3 Blade 100 Grain...

Innerloc Shape Shifter – 100 grain – 1- 1/4″ cutting diameter


Innerloc’s shape-shifting broadhead is an excellent mechanical broadhead for an arrow, flying rather dart-like and spreading on impact to cut into deer and other animals you’re hunting.

This pack comes with three broadheads and three ExoCovers, all of which are reusable in case you miss.

Notably, these broadheads are extremely accurate in the hands of trained archers, outperforming many of their competitors.

Specs:

  • Cutting Diameter: 1-1/4”
  • Weight: 100 grain

Tip:

  • Chisel Tip / Cut on Contact

Features & Benefits:

  • More accurate than most of its competitors
  • Excellent cutting diameter
  • Offers the benefits of both narrow and broadheads
  • Cuts wide enough to bleed targets out quickly

These are certainly fancier than fixed-shape broadheads, and they usually run more expensive as well. They also rattle around slightly in the plastic cover, but the pinpoint accuracy more than makes up for the few flaws these broadheads have.

Slick Trick Magnum

Slick Trick Magnum – 100 or 125 grain – 1 1/8″ cutting diameter


Slick Trick Magnum Broadheads have been around for an extensive period, and have been used by hunters far and wide to take an array of big game species.

Specs:

  • Cutting Diameter: 1 1/8″
  • Weight: 100 or 125 Grain

Tip:

  • Chisel Tip

Features & Benefits:

  • Four Blade
  • Alcatraz Bladelock technology for increased rigidity
  • Interchangeable replacement blades for ease of maintenance

These heads utilize .035 SS Lutz blades that securely lock into place with the use of the company’s Alcatraz Bladelock System.

This means that you gain the simplified maintenance characteristics of a replacement blade head with the strength and rigidity of a fixed blade broadhead.

These Slick Trick heads are also known for their high level of accuracy straight out of the package.

Muzzy Trocar 3-Blade – Fixed Broadhead Blades

Muzzy Trocar – 100 grain – 1 3/16″ cutting diameter


Muzzy is a name that needs no introduction, as the company has been producing top-tier broadheads for the bowhunting market since 1984.

The Trocar 3-Blade Broadhead carries on the company’s hard-hitting tradition with its hardened trocar tip and solid steel ferrule that will not deform, even when hitting bone. Delivers the kinetic energy where you want it.

Specs:

  • Cutting Diameter: 1 3/16”
  • Weight: 100 grain

Tip:

  • Chisel Tip 

Features & Benefits:

  • Hardened trocar tip for enhanced penetration
  • Replace Blade Broadhead
  • Right-helix blades for maximum arrow stabilization
  • Solid steel ferrule that resists deformation

The Muzzy Trocar 3-Blade also features .035” right-helix fixed blades that serve to stabilize arrow flight. 

Rage Mechanical Broadhead

Rage 2 Blade Broadhead, 100 Grain with...

Rage Mechanical Broadhead – 100 grain – 2″ cutting diameter


Rage Broadheads have been around for a number of years now, and have received much fanfare for the devastating wound channels that they leave behind. This is made possible by Rage’s 2” cut, mechanical blade broadhead.

read.. Rage Broadheads Hands-On Review

After a well-placed arrow has made contact, blood trails are seldom lengthy, and many hunters watch their game fall in sight.

Specs:

  • Cutting Diameter: 2”
  • Weight: 100 grain

Tip:

  • Cut-on-contact / Chisel Tip Hybrid

Features & Benefits:

  • Massive cutting diameter for devastating wound channels/blood trail
  • Expandable design allows field-tip-like flight characteristics
  • Shock Collar Technology
  • Replaceable blade for ease of maintenance

Superb arrow flight is yet another characteristic of note when considering the potential purchase of rage broadheads due to their slip-cam expandable design.


And The Winner is…

When comparing the broadheads presented on this list, I feel that the G5 Montec, with its fixed blade, is the best broadhead for elk, with the Magnus Stinger Buzzcut Broadheads coming in as a close runner-up.

G5 Outdoors Montec BassPro

G5 Outdoors Montec – 85-125 grain -1″- 1 1/8″ cutting diameter


The G5 Montec is built for unsurpassed and better penetration, made out of one piece and easily maintained with simple blade sharpening.

This makes the G5 Montec an extremely versatile option under several circumstances for any individual looking to make the most out of their elk hunt.

That said, match your broadhead with your bow setup and the energy you can deliver. A three-blade broadhead will require a more powerful setup.

If your setup is somewhat weaker and you are looking for great penetration and better accuracy, the Magnus Stinger Buzzcut is your broadhead. It´s a two-blade broadhead with two additional small bleeder blades.

Ideally, you want a complete “passthrough” through the vital organs, delivering lethal damage (as it may happen with a broadside shot).

Last update on 2024-06-23 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

1 thought on “Best Broadheads For Elk Hunting 2024”

  1. qad exodus, innerloc ss ,wasp boss 4 blade, wasp hammer,magnus snuffer, nap hell razor, ozcut 3, min 650 grain arrow footed for hard bone impacts. shooting 725 grain arrow 250 spine footed 72 lbs high country always a pass through. Never shoot a mechanical for elk , moose or brown bear. This setup peels the blades clean off a rage on a fresh cow shoulder bone, shrapnel for blades. good for deer and small game.

    Reply

Leave a Comment

crossbow outside leaning at a pole
Equipment/Gear
Darren Webster

Why Do Many Hunters Choose a Recurve Crossbow Instead of a Compound Crossbow?

You’re not living in the Stone Age, so why do many hunters like you choose a recurve crossbow instead of a compound crossbow? The answer is simplicity and reliability. The recurve crossbow’s design is straightforward, with fewer mechanical parts, making it less prone to mechanical failure and easier to maintain. Its lightweight and maneuverable design

Read More »
deer with antlers
Equipment/Gear
Darren Webster

Best Deer Scent Attractants

Imagine you’re nestled in your tree stand, the forest around you just stirring to life as dawn breaks. You’ve been there since the wee hours of the morning, armed with your bow and a thermos of steaming coffee, but the deer are proving elusive. You’ve done your homework, scouting the area, checking the wind direction,

Read More »
a deer standing in a field of pumpkins
Game/Wildlife
Alexander Knobloch

Do Deer Eat Pumpkins?

I received this question from a reader. I wanted to share it with you because I thought it was a good question – Would deer eat pumpkins? They sure do! This article will tell you all about the nutritional value of pumpkins and if you should feed them to deer.  Let’s get started… Do All

Read More »